Help us with a comment policy
By Gina Spadafori
July 22, 2009
The latest software upgrade allows the site moderators to stick a post on the top of the blog and leave it there permanently. I’m thinking of writing and posting a very short statement about comments, but I could us some help.
We don’t have posted comments guidelines now. The software is set to moderate the first post anyone makes, and it will also grab for moderation any post with more than two links. This is mostly to catch automated spam, and people who are paid to post links and run.
After someone has had a first comment approved, he or she is generally unmoderated. Usually commenters stay that way unless they’re banned, which we’ve had to do maybe 20-30 times in the last four years.
The things what will almost certainly earn someone a trip to Automatic Comment Vaporization Land is the persistent inability to discuss the issues. Repeating talking points over and over is pretty much a three-strike-and-you’re-out affair: We give you a couple of chances to catch on and engage your OWN brain, and if you can’t, you get the boot.
It’s not about agreeing with the bloggers here. That’s not necessary at all to get along here. But we do want the discussions to be discussions, not dogma yelps, and we want discussions to advance so everyone can get something out of them.
A couple of people have been thrown out of the game after a single pitch, but as was documented in “Bull Durham,” if you launch profanity-laced inventive at the umpire, you’re gone:
.
We need something clear and short. Toss your suggestions into the comments.
I won’t be around here much today. I have picked up a virus or something, and I’m heading back to bed … so toss in your suggestions and I’ll work out something when I feel better.
By the way, I almost certainly will be watching “Bull Durham” today. I always do when I’m sick. :)
By the way, we have almost 57,000 comments on this blog, on some 3,500 posts.
One more point: Sometimes the software has a mind of its own, and snags even our own comments. Usually when comments don’t show up, its because the spam filter grabbed them for whatever tomfool reason its little computer brain has cooked up. Lose a comment? Drop us an e-mail and we’ll fish it out of the spam folder.
Look, I know it’s nasty out there. My part-time “day job” is as a writer-editor with a wonderful
And Heather … oh, Queen Heather. My darling heart dog, my 11.5 year-old queen of the world (just ask her) will compete in 11-and-older veteran girls. This is special, because she is the Queen here, and because she has previously placed in two national specialties — as a puppy, and as a 7- to 9-year-old veteran girl.
Even better, Honda just confirmed that they’ll be sending me on the road trip in our 2007 Best In Show DogCar of the Year, the 