Christmas puppies: Testing my own advice
By Gina Spadafori
December 14, 2007
This morning just after dawn I slipped on the ice in my backyard. Ice. In California. Slipped, fell and landed with an embarassing and somewhat painful splat on my wood deck.
Why was I out on my wood deck in a nightgown, coat and clogs without socks at a little after dawn?
I was waiting for Otter to pee.
Of course, she wasn’t about to do that with me on the ground, and soon I was covered with sweet puppy kisses. I stood up as quickly as I could — not easy, since I was sure I had broken something — and then tried to encourage her to take care of her business.
Please, Otter. Please. Please. But oh no: She had found a leaf instead, and happily retrieved it for me. See? I’m a good puppy retriever? See? See?
What could I say? “Good girl, Otter,” I told her, taking the leaf she offered me. “Now puppy go potty before I freeze to death.”
Why would anyone want to raise a puppy in the winter? Even in California? I’ve long advised against the whole Christmas puppy thing for many reasons, key among them that Christmas puppies are usually available only from puppy-millers (either through pet stores of direct-sale Internet sites) or careless and clueless backyard breeders.
Aside from the philosophical reasons for not supporting such sellers, these puppies are often ill-equipped to be good pets: They’re often unsocialized and more likely to have congenital defects that will plague them throughout their lives. Do you need a neurotic pet with expensive health problems? If that’s no what you want, why not take the trouble to find a shelter or rescue dog from a group with an active foster program, or from a reputable, ethical breeder? No, you can’t whip out a credit card on a whim with these folks, but isn’t getting a pup with a head start worth a little research, effort and patience?
Seriously. Think about it.
But the practical matters are important, too: It’s flat-out more difficult to raise a puppy when the nights are cold and the days are short. You don’t just throw a puppy outside, after all, you have to house-train them — note the use of the term “house-train” rather then the ill-informed concept of house-breaking. To train, you limit their territory in the house, manage their timing and take them where you want them to go and praising them for getting it right. To break, you punish a puppy for making a mistake she doesn’t understand. How bloody unfair!
And what about the all-important socialization? That’s so much easier in the summer, too, because you can always find people at outdoor tables willing to pet a puppy. (I always take my puppies where people, not dogs are. Socialization needs to be safe before puppy immunizations are complete.) When it’s 40 degrees outside, you’re going to find many people at those outdoor tables. And you can’t take the puppy inside the Starbucks.
Longer days are better for training, too, even though some of that can of course be done inside.
But we’re coping, Otter and me. It’s just more work and more effort on my part. Otter isn’t really a “Christmas puppy” and she’s not even mine. I’m raising her for a friend, and she’ll go to that friend in April. That’s a lot of responsibility!
But when she does leave me, she’ll have all the basics covered, be healthy, well-trained and well-socialized. No matter how cold it is outide.
Given my druthers, I’d rather raise a puppy in the summer. And so should you.





I would personally MUCH prefer to raise a puppy in the winter, because I don’t mind the cold and the rain, but I hate hate hate the heat — and my deerhounds hate the heat, too.
But slipping on ice is bad… hope you’re okay!
Comment by Christie Keith — December 14, 2007 @ 11:30 am
What heat? You live in San Francisco. Sheesh.
:)
Comment by Gina Spadafori — December 14, 2007 @ 11:42 am
ouch, and haha..
I brought my puppy home from California last March.. right into a snowstorm the next weekend.
he had no choice but to learn to do his business in the cold
http://s154.photobucket.com/al.....000249.flv
and yes, it was many weeks of getting up to take him out in sub-freezing weather. Hope your boy figures it out quicker than mine did!
be careful in that ice!
Comment by EmilyS — December 14, 2007 @ 1:34 pm
Emily … I CAN’T BELIEVE you video’d that. LOL!
Comment by Gina Spadafori — December 14, 2007 @ 1:54 pm
We got our puppy in mid-November (in Oregon, where you can count on it raining sideways everyday.)She was trained in a jiff and goes potty on command. Who wants to be outside in a rainstorm to go potty? Not the dog, not me. It wound up being very efficient.
Comment by C.L.H. — December 14, 2007 @ 3:12 pm
Unfortunately, as a retriever Otter would consider the rain an additional reason to dawdle. :)
Comment by Gina Spadafori — December 14, 2007 @ 3:16 pm
Gina, what can I say.. he’s my first puppy; I have to capture every moment.
I seem to have a knack: this one is on Itchmo:
http://www.itchmo.com/itchmo-r.....re-39-4183
Comment by EmilyS — December 14, 2007 @ 4:37 pm
My oldest was 9 weeks old when I got her at the end of November many years ago. We’re on Canada’s south coast, and she learned right away to go out several times a day in freezing rain and snow. Being a northern spitz, she loved the snow. The rain on her little feet, not so much. Nothing has changed over the years. Can’t keep her in when there’s snow to play in. Had to invent a “wet dog” game so she’d go out when it rains.
A winter solstice baby myself, I think it gave us good preparation early on.
Comment by shibadiva — December 15, 2007 @ 8:52 am
Unless you live in Florida — then you don’t want a puppy in summer.
Comment by Debbie — December 15, 2007 @ 9:34 am
We brought Darcy home during a very rainy February here in SoCal and we have no yard, so she had no choice but to potty outdoors when it was wet or cold. It never bothered her. I figured since she came from Ireland she was probably used to that kind of weather anyway.
Comment by Kim Thornton — December 16, 2007 @ 5:25 pm